Join the Nation Do Your Part Stamp Out Bodysnarking
What kind of influence has your mom had on your body image?:
Video: Photobooth of Change, Body Image Edition
Video: Photobooth of Change, Body Image Edition

By Melanie Klein--My students and I talked back to mainstream media by creating our own  messages. We let them know that we're fed up with what we're being given and told them what we want.

Sometimes anger can spark real change, especially when it gets us to move away from thinking "What's wrong with me?" and start questioning what's wrong with a culture that makes us feel so bad about ourselves so much of the time. Margaret Cho knows a little something about that. She went off in a much-publicized and justified Twitter tirade last week. After being on the receiving end of some snarky comments about her body, Cho lost it. As she eloquently put it, "I blew a f****ing gasket. I screamed out loud and tracked the perps down and blocked them, but not before really ramming it to them in the strongest language I could use." For years she's been told she needed to lose more weight, she wasn't pretty enough, and worse. Cho reacted to this latest criticism in a massive, over-the-top rant, during which she basically told the haters to shove it.

When you're repeatedly told you don't meet the ridiculously narrow and unrealistic expectations of beauty, that negativity can mess with your head for a long time until you eventually just get sick of it...and then get totally pissed off. And the way I see it, getting pissed off is a whole lot healthier than retreating into self-hatred.

While not all of us have our anger at this body-hating injustice shared across the internet, it doesn't mean it doesn't exist or that it isn't valid. As I quoted in an earlier post:

It is that act of speech, of “talking back,” that is no mere gesture of empty words, that is the expression of our movement from object to subject – the liberated voice.” --bell hooks

 

About this blogger: Melanie Klein is an Associate Faculty member at Santa Monica College, teaching Sociology and Women’s Studies. She attributes feminism and yoga as the two primary influences in her work. She is committed to communal collaboration, raising consciousness, media literacy, facilitating the healing of distorted body images and promoting healthy body relationships. She has worked with the new citizen journalists of the LA Academy of Global Girl Media and the peer-educators of J.A.D.E (Joint Advocates on Disordered Eating) on ways to tap into the power of their own voice. She is the adviser of the Santa Monica College Feminist Majority Leadership Alliance and founder and co-coordinator of WAM! LA.Her work may also be found at Feminist FataleAdios Barbie, Elephant Journal, Ms. Magazine's blog and WIMN's Voices. She is featured in the forthcoming book, Conversations with Modern Yogis and the documentary, The American Housewife.

Leave a Comment?

Login to leave comments

Comments

Sat, 05/12/2012 - 06:19.
Ehendrie says:
I remember when we did that, and how I was SOOO totally hiding behind that piece of paper because I hate how I look on camera because they make me look SOOOOOO FAT, OMG. That was the skinniest I'd ever been in my life! (Oh, irony....)
Wed, 05/02/2012 - 04:09.
Tina402 says:
I agree that getting pissed off is better than holding the anger in, but we are told as women that it is not appropriate for us to show our anger. We are told how we need to look, what we should wear, how we should act... we will never be thin enough, pretty enough, wear the right clothes to please everyone so we should just aim to accept our self and be happy with who we are. The first step is to read blogs like these, take classes to increase our awareness about how we are manipulated by society and then take a long, friendly look in the mirror and get acquainted with who we really are.
Thu, 04/05/2012 - 02:51.
Salina G says:
Oh media, won't you just for one day, give the sexually explicit commercials and videos a rest, or make the anorexic men and women eat something like a Carl's Jr. bacon avocado burger, or put nothing but minorities on commercials and runways? Just for one day, can you? I think that will make a statement and maybe lead to a new fashion, a new way of life, a new line of clothing, a new face on the cover of Vogue, and rake in billions and trillions of dollars internationally, not just nationwide. How about it? It's time to stop being a follower and try being a leader and it is then maybe just maybe you will feel good about the kind of job you do. Just a suggestion, a strong one.
Sun, 04/01/2012 - 19:33.
JenniferH. says:
If I could talk back to the media, I would tell them: “You will not define who I am and how I should look, act, and dress.” I spent way too much time being preoccupied with my body’s shape and how I should dress. Throughout high school, I had to have the latest “trendy clothes” that the media stated would make me look “gorgeous.” Eventually, once I started attending college and became aware of the media’s deceit, I stopped caring about their views. I have never and will never look like the media portrays women to be super thin and tall. It has felt extremely empowering to just stop paying close attention to the media and what they define as beautiful. The relief I have been feeling is extraordinary because the media robbed me from a more happy and stress- free teenage hood. But, I am now happier with whom I am and I have excluded the media as much as possible from my life. This way I am not constantly told about why I “should change” my body; but rather I can decide how I want to look and feel about myself. Also, I am teaching my eleven year- old sister that the media nor anyone else has the right to tell her whether she is or is not beautiful; we are all uniquely gorgeous in our on ways. The media needs to accept this and realize we are humans, not robots that can be constantly scrutinized. On that note, we also need more self- loving education in the school systems and at home.
Tue, 02/07/2012 - 09:19.
Antoniacarlotta says:
It would be great if more people would reject the mainstream media's portrayal of beautiful and insist upon proper representation of themselves. The video posted above represents 6 minutes worth of individuals all rejecting the messages being forced upon us daily and they're just a tiny sample of people across the country who would be thrilled with media reform. The post makes an important point when it says we need to stop questioning ourselves and start questioning the culture we live in that encourages us to feel so poorly about ourselves. I truly appreciate Margaret Cho and other figures who stand up against the mainstream who try to confine them to certain standards. Margaret has never been one to shy away from controversy or standing up for her beliefs and I think she has helped to take great strides in awareness of women's rights and unrealistic standards in society. It's a fact that expressing your feelings (even those out of anger) results in a healthier self as you don't bottle up your emotions or take the pain out on yourself spiritually or physically. It's a shame that we've been driven to a place of such anger but I think in the end it will actually send a stronger message and result in a more unified front if all feminist thinkers get mad together and demonstrate these unrealistic cultural expectations won't be accepted anymore.
Tue, 02/07/2012 - 01:04.
Rorincent says:
This video really spoke to me as I think it is extremely important for people in today's society and especially women to realize that they look good just the way they are. Like the video says no one can look the way that people are portrayed in the media and it is extremely unfair for that type of body to be pushed upon everyone. There is no right or wrong way to look and however you look should be the right way for you. I really want to see an increase in this movement where young women especially are compelled to stand up and realize that they are beautiful right now, right the way they are.
Mon, 02/06/2012 - 19:28.
Leeesakiim says:
I just want to thank all the women who have spoken out by demanding what is really needed and things that would help out their own selves and each other. It's really powerful to see that women are gathered in a place to go over what is needed and what they should be appreciated for. I'm sure many or all have learned things about themselves that they will never forget. This became the perfect opportunity to settle on their identities that make them happy without having to feel like they aren't worth it. By first having a great bond with yourself builds up self love that becomes incapable of being removed other than yourself. It crucial that we begin to respect and love our own selves and bodies before we do so with others. Not only is it dangerous for ourselves but to others by giving misrepresentation of ideas or mixed feelings that aren't clear and causes relationships to be at sake or at uneasy levels. Advocates of this project should be proud to serve more women to heal and empower the women in need of fellow members who struggle with the same sorts of issues.
Mon, 02/06/2012 - 06:40.
Lam Yan Yee says:
I love this video. This video tells the people what we need. And there is a comment which is I am who I am. I really love this sentence. People should not use Photoshop to change their face or body. If you use Photoshop, he or she is not you anymore. We should love ourselves. Our parents gave all this things to us and we should appreciate.
Mon, 02/06/2012 - 02:33.
Eun Hee Chung says:
It was great video. Through this video, I thought that media give advantages but this time, medias are giving lots of disadvantages. Especially, media gives us unrealistic messages or images of beauty that the media portrays. All magazines models are skinny and and clean skin but most of magazine’s pictures are fixing with photoshop. At times the mass media is not a good inspiration to women.
Mon, 02/06/2012 - 01:35.
Rosemary A says:
This video and especially this project is great! It definitely teaches students and people of society how important it is to accept ourselves for what we are rather than to be listening to what the media considers acceptable and mainstream. It is teaching people to leave the insecurities the media is placing upon us and to open our eyes to what really matters. We need to accept that each of us were born differently, we all have our own genes so it doesn’t make sense to listen to the stereotypical media representations ofb eauty but to accept what we have naturally.
Stamp Out Bodysnarking